Sheepshead Bay Marketplace

1669 Reviews (4.4 Rating)
Advertisement

The business details and user reviews shown for Sheepshead Bay Marketplace are based on information sourced from Google Maps. This place has a total of 1669 reviews on Google, but for performance and readability we display up to the 15 most recent reviews on our website.
If you are the owner or representative of this business and would like it to be removed from our directory, please use the "Remove Request" button at the top of this page. All information is provided for informational purposes only and may not always reflect the most recent changes made on Google Maps.

This listing for Sheepshead Bay Marketplace was first added to our directory on December 18, 2025 based on the information available at that time. It is currently listed as a Grocery store in Brooklyn, US.

15 Reviews for Sheepshead Bay Marketplace

Jean Farrell

6 months ago

I was there for the first time today. The store looks very nice and clean. They have a wide variety of products. With that being said, I will not be returning due to the high prices and rude, disrespectful treatment from the employees. I …

ko gl

6 months ago

I am a long-time customer who regularly shops at your store and have generally enjoyed the experience. However, I am very disappointed by a recent issue that has made me reconsider continuing to shop with you. …

Michael Gofman

2 weeks ago

Excellent fruit selection. Must try the nuts and dry fruit section as well. Lots of other great items.

ELI “TEENY-BOP” Poppin'Fresh

3 years ago

I love the coffee and of course the deals.
Everything is so fresh and colorful. I've eaten A yellow watermelon but never an orange watermelon.
This place is awesome.

Shannon Shenanigans

6 months ago

I went to this store for the first time ever today. While shopping for fruit, one of the employees started screaming at me to move out of his way. He was unbelievably and over the top nasty which was uncalled for since all he had to say was …

Val Prestoff

Edited 7 years ago

The best store for healthy food in Brooklyn guaranteed. They have lots of organic produce for great prices. The environment and aura are awesome, I simply love buying there.

Zamir Mustafayev

3 months ago

We bought a watermelon there, and it was both expensive and very bad inside. When we went back to let them know, they said they didn’t care. Very unprofessional attitude. Avoid this place.

Shukhrat Maks

4 years ago

Well organized supermarket with variety of produces. I have tried pastries, Napoleon cake. Very tasty and delicious. Will come back for more pastries to try. Also, I have noticed that employees are keep filling up the produces and always …

Tam B

7 years ago

Clean with great service. Lots of fresh and inexpensive produce, cold cuts, bread. Their Deli is like non I have ever seen. The bakery offers a variety of amazing desserts. I always go there for my deli and grocery. The poundage area is wonderful with hot and cold meals. This location is close to buses and trains.

Fred Alluso

7 years ago

I have walked past numerous times and only entered once to quickly grab some greens. I remember as I left that the store appeared to be quite large and would probably be worth a complete review after shopping. …

Kristina25 K

7 months ago

They have great selection of desserts — from rich, chocolates to beautifully crafted pastries. Every piece looked like it was made with real care and artistry. The cashier was exceptionally friendly and welcoming, She recommended me Amazing Dubai Chocolate, it was super fresh and delicious. I highly recommend this store.

Steven Nechamkin

a year ago

The large supermarket is located in the Sheepshead Bay section of Brooklyn. They are open 7 days a week for 24 hours everyday. They have a wide variety of fruits and vegetables, dairy, meat and beverages. Customers can select various hot …

liza s

a month ago

They have a great selection of items. I would really prefer if their hot bar of food had covers especially ones on ledge closest to customers. I dont want food that other people breathe on constantly. It feels like a health violation

Samir Babayev

3 months ago

POISONOUS FOOD ALERT!
NEVER EVER BUY FROM THIS PLACE!
This marketplace sold me a watermelon that looked fine outside, but when we …

Janet Miletti

6 days ago

I love this store. There fruits are always fresh sweet hold for a longer time in fridge, veggies are amazing also. Prepared foods are so yummy I love there calamari cooked perfect nvr over cooked there salads are delicious baked fish …